Skip to main content Skip to navigation

The Solutions Trial

Project Lead

Name: Samantha Flynn

Title: Associate Professor

Profile Link:

Samantha Flynn | About | The University of Warwick

Project Team

Samantha Flynn (co-PI)

Peter Langdon (University of Birmingham) (co-PI)

Paul Thompson (University of Birmingham) (Trial Statistician)

Gwenllian Moody (University of Cardiff) (Trial Manager)

Plus Project Team and Trial Management Group

Project Dates

Start Date: 01/06/2022

End Date: 30/06/2027

Funder

Youth Endowment Fund

About The Project

Children and young people who come into contact with the police often need help. This trial aims to test out whether offering these children and young people a psychological treatment called Solution-Focused Brief Therapy (SFBT) is helpful. SFBT is a short-term therapy that helps people to change by focusing on building solutions rather than getting stuck thinking about problems. We want to find whether this treatment works by running a clinical trial. We will give some children and young people SFBT plus the routine treatment (Support As Usual or SAU) that they would normally get. Other children and young people will only get the routine treatment that is currently offered when they come into contact with the police. We will decide who gets which treatment at random, which is like flipping a coin.

In order to work out whether SFBT is helpful, our trial has two parts. In the first part, we will run what is called a ‘pilot’. This is a test version of the trial which tests whether the trial can be run. If we find that this is the case, we will then move to the second part, which is continuing with the main trial by inviting more children and young people to take part.

All of the children and young people who take part will be asked to complete some measures of things that may change because of taking part in SFBT. We are particularly interested in whether they are involved in any antisocial behaviours over the course of the trial. We will also ask about their background, their general well-being, any criminal activity they have been involved with in the past and any gang connections. We will also interview some of the children and young people receiving SFBT, their parents/guardians, and the professionals who deliver the SFBT therapy. We will ask them about their experiences of taking part in the trial.

Project Aims

In the proposed research, we will conduct a randomised controlled trial with process evaluation and internal pilot (to assess trial feasibility) where children and young people (CYP) presenting at a police custody suite will be randomly allocated to receive Solution Focused Brief Therapy (SFBT) plus Support as Usual (SAU) or SAU alone to evaluate reduction in offending behaviours.

Project Objectives

The primary objective of this trial is to determine whether there is a benefit of SAU plus SFBT over SAU alone in reducing offending behaviours in 10–17-year-olds presenting at a police custody suite.

The secondary objectives are to:

  • Complete an internal pilot in the first seven months to examine whether moving to a definitive trial is warranted and feasible.
  • Generate evidence to consider whether SFBT + SAU reduces externalising and internalising behaviours.
  • Examine whether there is a relationship between changes in externalising and internalising behaviours and changes in offending behaviours.
  • Carry out exploratory sub-group analyses of outcomes by Learning Disability (LD) status, and callous- unemotional traits.
  • Monitor and report any adverse events related to SFBT.
  • Complete a process evaluation using key indicators drawn from the logic model, including an evaluation of acceptability and the experiences of children, young people, parents/guardians, and other key stakeholders (e.g., practitioners, delivery team) and fidelity of delivery of SFBT.
  • Explore availability of routine data sources.
  • Explore how any reduction in offending behaviour relates to critical moments of school exclusion.

Let us know you agree to cookies