Marking criteria (written) Chinese/Japanese/Korean 3/4
Class |
Scale |
Percentage (Mark) |
Language (60% )
-accuracy & appropriateness of vocab and grammar -range of vocab and grammar -use of complex sentence structures -accuracy in characters & punctuation
|
Content and communication(40% )
-understanding of the text - fulfilment of the task -response to the task -ideas -organisation (-argumentation where applies) (-appropriate register where applies
|
||
First |
Excellent 1st |
100
|
Work of original and exceptional quality. Merits special recognition Exemplary piece of writing |
|||
Exemplary accuracy and appropriateness in vocabulary and grammar Exemplary use of a wide range of vocabulary and grammar Highly effective use of complex sentence structures throughout Virtually no mistakes in characters and punctuation
|
Exemplary understanding of the text
Task fulfilled beyond expectations
Exceptionally sophisticated, original and skilful response to the task Exemplary ideas Exemplary organisation (Where expected,) highly persuasive and effective argumentation (Where expected,) excellent use of register
|
|||||
94
|
Exceptional work of the highest quality Exceptional piece of writing |
|||||
Exceptionally accurate and appropriate use of vocabulary and grammar Exceptionally wide range of vocabulary and grammar Effective use of complex sentence structures throughout Hardly any mistakes in characters and punctuation |
Exceptional understanding of the text Task fulfilled to the highest expectations Sophisticated, original and skilful response to the task Exceptional ideas Exceptional organisation (Where expected,) highly persuasive and effective argumentation (Where expected,) excellent use of register |
|||||
High 1st High Mid 1st
|
88
82
|
Very high quality work Outstanding piece of writing |
||||
Outstanding accuracy and appropriate use of vocabulary and grammar, with only a small number of minor errors Outstanding range of vocabulary and grammar Appropriate use of complex sentence structures throughout Only a few mistakes in characters and punctuation
|
Outstanding understanding of the text Task fulfilled fully and effectively Very clear and appropriate response to task with some originality Outstanding ideas Outstanding organisation (Where expected,) coherent and effective argumentation (Where expected,) excellent use of register |
|||||
Low Mid 1st
Low 1st |
78
74 |
Very high quality work Excellent piece of writing |
||||
Excellent accuracy and appropriate use of vocabulary and grammar with occasional minor mistakes. Excellent range of vocabulary and grammar Generally complex sentence structures are used appropriately Appropriate use of complex sentence structures Only occasional mistakes in characters and punctuation
|
Excellent understanding of the text Task fulfilled fully Clear and appropriate response to task Excellent ideas Excellent organisation (Where expected,) coherent and sufficiently effective argumentation (Where expected,) excellent use of register |
|||||
Upper Second (2.1) |
High 2.1
|
68
|
Very good piece of writing
|
|||
Very good accuracy and appropriate use of vocabulary and grammar There are some errors including isolated cases of a few major mistakes. But generally they don’t impede the intended meaning Very good range of vocabulary and grammar Complex sentence structures are attempted and well executed Most characters and punctuation are correct.
|
Very good understanding of the text Very good fulfilment of all aspects of the task Clear response Very good ideas Very good organisation (Where expected,) coherent and well-developed argumentation (Where expected,) very good use of register
|
|||||
Mid 2.1
|
65
|
Good piece of writing
|
||||
Good accuracy and appropriate use of vocabulary and grammar There are some errors, including some major mistakes. But in most cases, intended meaning is clear Good range of vocabulary and grammar Complex sentence structures are attempted and generally well executed
Most characters and punctuation are correct |
Good understanding of the text Generally good fulfilment of all aspects of the task, or very good fulfilment of most aspects of the task Clear response Some very good ideas Good organisation (Where expected,) coherent and sufficiently developed argumentation (Where expected,) very good use of register
|
|||||
Low 2.1
|
62
|
Mostly good piece of writing
|
||||
Mostly good accuracy and appropriate use of vocabulary and grammar There are some errors, including some persistent minor mistakes and some more major mistakes. But in most cases, intended meaning is still recognisable Good range of vocabulary and structures Complex sentence structures are attempted but not always executed competently Most characters and punctuation are correct
|
Mostly good understanding of the text Good fulfilment of most aspects of the task Reasonably clear response Good ideas Mostly good organisation (Where expected,) coherent argumentation with some development (Where expected,) good use of register
|
|||||
Lower Second (2.2) |
High 2.2
|
58
|
Adequate piece of writing |
|||
Adequate accuracy and appropriate use of vocabulary and grammar There are a noticeable number of errors. Most of them are minor, but some may be serious enough to affect meaning in parts. Simple structures are used reasonably correctly, but complex structures tend to be erroneous Range of vocabulary and structures is somewhat limited but adequate for the communication Although there are some mistakes in characters, they are largely still recognizable. The punctuation is adequate.
|
Adequate understanding of the text Reasonable fulfilment of many aspects of the task Most of the main points are addressed and expanded, but others are developed in a partial or simple manner Reasonable ideas Adequate organisation (Where expected,) largely coherent and supported argumentation (Where expected,) Satisfactory use of register
|
|||||
Mid 2.2
|
55
|
Mostly adequate piece of writing |
||||
Mostly adequate accuracy and appropriate use of grammar and vocabulary There are a significantly noticeable number of errors. Intended meaning can be difficult to understand in some parts. Simple structures are often used correctly, but complex structures are often erroneous Range of vocabulary and structures is somewhat limited and simple Although there are some mistakes in characters, they are largely still recognizable
|
Mostly adequate understanding of the text Adequate fulfilment of the task Many of the main points are addressed. However some of them are developed in an unclear or insufficient manner Mostly adequate ideas Mostly adequate organisation (Where expected,) coherent and supported argumentation (Where expected,) Satisfactory use of register
|
|||||
Low 2.2 |
52
|
Adequate piece of writing |
||||
Accuracy and appropriate use of grammar and vocabulary is satisfactory, but limited
There are a very significantly noticeable number of errors. and some are so serious that intended meaning is unclear in some parts. Simple structures are often used correctly, but complex structures are often erroneous. Range of vocabulary and structures is limited and this affects the depth of communication. Although there are some mistakes in characters, they are largely still recognizable.
|
Reasonably adequate understanding of the text Satisfactory fulfilment of the task but with some limitations. Many of the main points are addressed but overall somewhat in an unclear or simple manner. Some adequate ideas. Satisfactory organization with some lack of clarity (Where expected,) reasonably coherent and partially supported argumentation (Where expected,) Satisfactory use of register.
|
|||||
Third |
High 3rd
Mid 3rd
Low 3rd
|
48
45
42
|
Work of limited quality Limited piece of writing |
|||
Limited proficiency in accurate and appropriate use of grammar and vocabular Grammatical mistakes are frequent, which impede comprehension in many parts The range of vocab and structures are fairly limited. Over all it tends to use more simple vocab and structures Only occasional attempts to use some complex vocab and structures, but attempts are often unsuccessful
Mistakes in writing characters are evident. |
Limited understanding of the text Limited fulfilment of the task Partial response Main points are addressed in a limited or minimum way Or some parts may be reasonably well expressed, but other parts are omitted or barely mentioned Limited organisation Ideas and reasons are presented, but not in a coherent manner Inconsistencies in register
|
|||||
Fail |
High Fail |
38
|
Work does not meet standards required for the level. Evidence of study and demonstrates some knowledge and skills. Unsatisfactory piece of writing |
|||
Unsatisfactory accuracy and appropriate use of grammar and vocabulary Most sentences contain errors and the number of errors makes comprehension difficult.
Vocabulary and structures used tend to be simple. |
Unsatisfactory understanding of the text Unsatisfactory response Response is attempted, but unsuccessfully Some of the main points may be mentioned, but they are inadequately or unclearly expressed Unsatisfactory organisation Generally incoherent and/or irrelevant argument
Inappropriate register |
|||||
Fail |
32
|
Work is significantly below the standard required for the level. Very unsatisfactory piece of writing |
||||
Inadequate accuracy and appropriate use of grammar and vocabulary
Some evidence of study and skills acquired, but subject to very serious omissions and errors. |
Vocab and structures are very simple and erroneous. It is difficult to understand even the gist Inadequate understanding of the text Very unsatisfactory response Response is attempted, but incompletely and unsuccessfully Inadequate organisation Some ideas are presented but there is no logical development |
|||||
25
12
|
Poor quality work well below the standards required for the level. Wholly unsatisfactory piece of writing |
|||||
Low Fail |
Occasional recognizable words and sentences but they make little sense |
Little evidence of grammatical/lexical competence Or not enough language to assess Failed response Most task elements missing. Wholly inadequate grasp of the main issues. |
||||
Zero |
Zero |
0 |
Work of no merit OR Absent, work not submitted, penalty in some misconduct cases |
Work of no merit OR Absent, work not submitted, penalty in some misconduct cases |