What does ‘being modern’ mean? The current pandemic brings this perennial question once again to the fore. Is a strong centralised state that enforces strict public health measures to save lives ‘modern’? Or is a free society where people can make their own choices and control their own body ‘modern’? Is a population that firmly believes in science over all other values ‘modern’? Or is a society where there is no single fundamental assumption, but only constant scepticism and debate ‘modern’? Taking cues from Ruth Rogaski's Hygienic Modernity (2004), Bobby Tam seeks to complicate the idea of what 'modern' is based on his observations of the pandemic response in the UK, Hong Kong, and Singapore.