In a supervised, time restricted, open-book examination students are able to bring some pre-decided resource, such as personal notes, a textbook or other resource. Students can refer to the resource during the examination, potentially reducing demands of recall or memorisation. Assessments can thus focus on analysis, criticality or creative thinking.
Open-book examinations, depending on how they are conceived, can assess:
organisation and application of information under time constraints
critical thinking and analytical skills
problem solving in discipline specific contexts
construction of coherent, evidence based arguments
synthesis of ideas and connections between topics
clarity and precision in written communication
time management and prioritisation under pressure
Variants:
Open-book, online examinations where access to certain online materials is permitted.
Unsupervised open-book examinations where students work in a physical space of their choice.
24-hour open-book online examinations where students sit the assessment at the time of their choice within a time window.
Open-book examinations can address some of the drawback of written examinations, particularly reducing the necessity to ‘cram’ by learning facts during examination preparation. Offering the opportunity to undertake some preparation can also help improve the quality of the work produced in the examination, making the experience more rewarding for students. When preparing such an assessment is it especially important to be clear about what information is provided about the examination questions in advance and what type of preparation will be useful. Furthermore, it is necessary to decide whether the materials students can bring to the examination are restricted to specified items or left unrestricted and at their discretion.
Questions to consider when preparing open-book examinations:
Are the questions sufficiently challenging to prevent simple copying or searching from notes or textbooks, rewarding integration of sources rather than their retrieval?
Is it clear what materials students are permitted to take into the examination (e.g. notes, readings, websites, calculators)? How will this be monitored?
What is the risk of students inappropriately relying on generative AI during the examination or in their preparation?
Is the time allocation appropriate for an open‑book task (given there may be longer but more analytical questions)?
Is the level of demand reasonable given the number and complexity of questions, and the time available?
Are instructions, expectations and answer formats clearly communicated and unambiguous?
Are questions free from unnecessary linguistic complexity that might disadvantage students with diverse backgrounds?
If online, does the design account for students with varying home environments, technology access, or internet reliability?
Are additional time allowances or alternative arrangements required for students with disabilities or approved reasonable adjustments?
Does the mark scheme reward higher‑order thinking commensurate with open‑book assessment?
When you set an open‑book exam, clear guidance about expectations and permitted materials helps reduce uncertainty, especially for students unfamiliar with this format. You are advised to focus questions on interpretation and application rather than access to particular texts, as not all students have the same resources or prior experiences. It is also important to ensure materials are accessible for those using assistive technologies, and consider whether time limits unintentionally disadvantage some learners. Thoughtful design supports a fairer, more inclusive assessment environment and better reflects the range of ways students demonstrate understanding.
Academic integrity in open‑book exams relies on students demonstrating their own understanding rather than copying or relying excessively on external sources. Clear expectations can help by explaining what forms of collaboration, citation, and resource use are permitted so students can act confidently and ethically (including use of GenAI). Well‑designed questions that require interpretation, analysis, or application naturally discourage misconduct by making simple lookup answers insufficient. It is also worth reminding students that integrity supports their learning and future practice, not just compliance. When exams are framed as opportunities for genuine engagement they help foster a culture where integrity feels both achievable and meaningful.
Staff and student experience
Allows students to consult materials, so questions can focus on application, analysis, evaluation or synthesis. This can encourage higher‑order thinking, rather than rewarding memorisation.
More closely aligned with real‑world professional practice where it is be common to consult sources, manuals, research papers and other tools. The assessment method is therefore more authentic than written, closed-book examinations.
Can result in higher quality responses because of the targeted preparation and resources available during the examination.
Lower test anxiety because students are not expected to memorise large amounts of content, potentially leading to a more representative performance for students who struggle with closed‑book formats.
Potentially supports inclusion by reducing disadvantages linked to memory difficulties, language barriers and other disabilities.
Risk of poor question design with questions that are too straightforward or based on recall, enabling student to replicate their notes and failing to assess understanding.
Over‑reliance on pre-prepared materials could mean some students spend too much time searching notes, reading textbooks or checking websites. This can reduce the time available for thinking and writing, leading to weaker responses.
Requirements to prepare materials in advance may increase the overall workload for students.
Unequal digital access may mean not all students have quiet study spaces, fast internet or reliable devise, disproportionately affecting some students and meaning the assessment is not fair.
Unsupervised take‑home and online have academic integrity risks with potential for collusion, plagiarism, inappropriate use of AI tools or other unauthorised assistance. Clear guidance and intelligent question design can help mitigate these.
Marking might be more complex and time consuming because responses are more varied and analytical.
The initial workload implications can be significant because students can consult materials and therefore questions must be crafted to assess higher‑order thinking rather than recall, which takes more time and intellectual effort to design. You need to ensure that prompts encourage analysis, synthesis, and application and this often involves creating authentic scenarios or data sets rather than relying on traditional question banks.
Additionally, open‑book formats demand thoughtful moderation and review to ensure consistency and fairness, especially when questions allow for diverse approaches. While this upfront investment can be substantial, it often results in richer assessments that better reflect students’ abilities and reduce grading disputes.