‘What was the principal impact of the Reformation on Germany?’ - please post your (max. 100 word) answer by replying to this thread
Module Forum: Reformation, Politics & Rebellion (HI242)
Module Forum: Reformation, Politics & Rebellion (HI242)
Reformation impact
You need to be logged in to post in this topic.
-
0 likes
-
In my opinion the principal long-term impact of the reformation regarding to Germany would be the politicisation of individuals and disenchantment that took place regarding religion. Events such as the Peasants War allows us to see that people were becoming more willing to take beliefs into their own hands and challenge flaws that they saw within the Catholic church. Thus, culminating in a form of grudged religious tolerance that had not been seen previously within the empire. As a result, this began a wave of education and religious awareness within the country and marked a separation from other Catholic Empires.
0 likes -
I would argue that the principal impact of the Reformation on Germany was political. The Reformation was used by various people as a way to bargain and reason for more power. In particular, the princes effectively used the Reformation to derive more rights and independence from the emperor via the Schmalkalden League. Though the League was defeated by Charles, Germany was soon hugely impacted by the Peace of Augsburg. The Peace allowed princes and territories to make their own political decisions, causing Germany to become more divided. Hence, the Reformation had a huge impact on Germany’s political landscape.
0 likes -
I would argue that the principal impact of the Reformation in Germany was division and disunity. Princely aspirations and groups such as the Schmalkaldic League perpetuated, often violent, divisions along branch lines. These relations were only further complicated through the different denominations that arose and their differentiating treatment by the state, such as the exclusion of Calvinists in the Peace of Augsburg, generating animosity even within the different branches. This division would spread across the continent, and lead to horrific conflicts such as the Thirty Years War, presenting how the reformation had a principal impact on the unity of Germany.
0 likes -
In the context of 16th century Europe the Reformation succeeded because it could no longer be treated as a heretical movement. Previously where Catholics had cried heresy and violently put down individuals such as Jan Hus to maintain the status quo, Martin Luther and other theologians succeeded in establishing a movement that forced recognition from the Catholic church and the secular powers at be. In this theological, religious and confessional realm the Reformation comprehensively changed the religious makeup of Europe but it had its limitations. The position of the peasantry and women despite promising inclinations towards reform remained largely unchanged and in many areas the secular powers maintained control of their lands regardless of whether they agreed with the Reformers or not.
0 likes -
The principal impact of the Reformation was surely its impact on people's everyday lives,. Though broader political, economic, and social elements also witnessed profound change, it is hard to understate the fundamental shift people experienced in their day-to-day existence. Religion was no longer uniform; the Church no longer held the only keys to heaven, and the divine became contested on a scale probably inconceivable before 1517. Relations within and between communities all became overlaid with potential religious differences. This shift in relationships and experience was the most fundamental and dramatic break with the past, and therefore the Reformation's primary impact.
0 likes -
I think I would argue that the principle impact was a change in societal structure, both secular and religious structure were, in my opinion detrimental to society and affected its future. Luther's ideas for an increase in princely power, affected the allegiance people had towards the emperor and thus changed its power dynamic. Secondly, the change in religious structure allowed people to think for themselves, the change with mass and the bible, meant that fundamental parts of Catholic beliefs were dismantled and effectively had altered Catholic unity so much so that a church council had to be called.
0 likes -
The most important impact of the Reformation was the political rebalancing of power between princely territories and the Emperor, namely the religious self-determination which was secured by the Peace of Augsburg. This, along with lesser but still important factors such as the consolidation of the family unit and changing attitudes to death and work, was important because it was integral to paving the way for modernity and demarcating between medieval and modern German history. The political and territorial transformation was thus the most significant impact of the Reformation because other impacts would not have been possible without the Reformation becoming a conflict of political contestation within the Empire, rather than mere abstracted theological debate. Only through this did the embedding of reformation become possible.
0 likes -
The principal impact of the Reformation was arguably the effect upon the daily lives of people in Germany, specifically those of the lower classes. Whilst changes occurred within the economy, political landscape, and religion collectively, the individualism created by such changes was unprecedented. Borne from Luther’s doctrine, the relationship between the individual and God was irrevocably altered, in turn affecting the societal structures in which the Church previously held supremacy. Thus, parishes began to dictate their personal requirements within their local churches, seen in the Wendelstein Ordinances (1524). Therefore, the localities became acutely aware of their agency, allocated to them within the wider transformations of the Reformation.
0 likes -
The principal impact of the Reformation on Germany was in terms of politics. Not only were such consequences immediate it resulted in the notion of state over the church itself. Paving the way for an increase in autonomy for the princes, it produced an alliance between state and the Church. The Peace of Augsburg of 1555 reflects this since it allowed princes the choice of the religion of their domains. Accompanied by events such as the Thirty Years War, such factors allowed for the development of individualism and democracy, drifting individual thought and power from religious to secular. Perhaps suggesting that the principal impact was in fact political in nature defining shaping modern Europe.
0 likes -
The German Reformation made fundamental changes to Church teachings, leading to further political and social reforms. Luther's three principles: sola scriptura, sola gratia and sola fide, changed how religion was viewed within society and formed the key Protestant and Catholic divisions that exist today. Good works were no longer required for the afterlife, challenging the use of indulgences and the authority of Catholic leaders. Religion was thus made more personal, with greater congregation involvement and regional decision making. This challenge of Catholic power was important for religious reasons but also greatly influenced later political reforms and societal structures.
0 likes -
In my opinion, the main impact of the Reformation was on how political decisions were made. Inspired by the words of Luther, peasants used vehicles such as the Peasants' War in 1525 to campaign for improvements in their socio-economic conditions, although with limited success. Political control was also shifted away from the Catholic Church towards secular authorities, such as princes and city councils, particularly in education policy. Luther's focus on sola scriptura and the priesthood of all believers also sparked an important political discussion about an increased role for individual laity in local decision-making.
0 likes -
The principal impact of the Reformation on Germany was the impact on the lives of the masses. The political geography of Germany and the Empire became increasingly complex, and even more so on a local level. Imperial free cities were representative of this, when following the Peace of Augsburg, they were often bi-confessional. Also, it radically transformed the relationship between people and God. Luther's theology removed the need for an intermediary figure, and principles such as sola scriptura and the priesthood of all believers were liberating for many members of the laity.
0 likes -
The principal impact of the Reformation on Germany would be the development in the operations to do with religion and the impact this had on the lives of the German people. The fact that the population had to adapt from being told their existence in the afterlife depended on their ability to perform good works and pilgrimages, being heavily encouraged to essentially buy their way into heaven, evolving into developing a spiritual, more personal connection with God as a result in the change of faith, thanks mostly to Martin Luther and the reforms he pushed for, for the Church structure.
0 likes -
The principle impact of the Reformation in Germany was the increase of social awareness about different views. Before the Reformation, the German population was expected to believe what they were told to believe in. When the reformation spread with preachers, pamphlets and an attempt to increase education, people for the first time were encouraged to think differently and critically about their position and beliefs. Although once the Reformation became more stabilised the princes and rulers of each region decided what religion it’s people would practice, people still had the choice to move between regions to practice their religion and were able to exercise their religious freedom far more than they thought possible before.
0 likes -
In my opinion, the principal impact of the Reformation on Germany, was the fragmentation and division it created within the Empire. This division was coupled with the boost to the process of territorialisation that Luther’s vesting of his church in the hands of the princes created. This growth of princely power coupled with the bi-confessional nature of the Empire, would lead to significant divisions with the Imperial Diet. This weakening of the power of the emperor, is exemplified by the breakdown of the Imperial Peace in the years and decades following the Reformation.
0 likes -
I believe that the principal impact of the Reformation on Germany was the social impact, and how the lives of the masses were changed. The mass mobilisation that occurred, evident through the Peasants’ War in 1525, as a result of the religious changes brought about by Luther is part of this. Therefore, Luther’s break from the Catholic Church contained a broad appeal to the peasants, highlighting them as more self-aware. The different interpretations of the words of the Gospel created more radical movements than Lutheranism in Germany, evidenced by the Anabaptists and their Kingdom of Munster. Consequently, the principal impact of the Reformation in Germany was the impact on people’s everyday lives, and how the differences and breaks between different sects forged this.
0 likes -
I would argue that the primary impact of the Reformation was more so secular. The shift in government and increased control secular authorities had over traditionally clerical responsibilities was a substantial change. Moreover, the Reformation could be seen as a shift from the medieval ages to the early modern or even modern period for Germany with major social and economic consequences.
0 likes -
A primary legacy of the Reformation was the birth of a "mass culture" within Germany. The politicisation of society transformed the function of visual media, realising it's propagandistic potential. Though the creation of the printing press proceeded the reformation, it was the rampant pamphleteering of Reformists who truly recognised the function of media as a political tool. Much is also to be said on the employment propagandistic woodcuts depicting the papacy as the "whore of Babylon." Such a transformation would fundamentally change the manner in which individuals and communities engaged with worldly affairs.
0 likes -
One big impact was the spread of literacy. Luther wanted Christians to read the the bible and universal schooling was fostered in Protestant areas. The literacy rate increased and Luther's choice to publish in German instead of Latin made the ideas of the Reformation more accessible to common people. The spread and promotion of education was overall a significant impact of the Reformation as it was a central way of spreading the Lutheran message.
0 likes