Skip to main content Skip to navigation

Listen to the Skillscast - our podcast!

The Skillscast is a podcast all about how you can learn and develop your skills while at University, and use them to set yourself up for a fantastic start to life once you graduate. It is brought to you by the team behind the Warwick Award and new episodes release every two weeks.

You can follow Skillscast on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, or wherever else you listen. You can also find each episode on this page, along with an AI-generated transcript.

Season 2 has landed!

Season 2

Season 2 Episode 16 -Shorts - Giving Feedback

Not sure how to give the right feedback, in the right way, at the right time? Are you worried about how it might impact your relationship with who you give feedback to? Check out this short to get you started on improving your feedback practices.

George Haughie: [00:00:00] Hello and welcome to Skillscast Shorts. Skillscast is the podcast from the University of Warwick looking at how to learn and develop skills while at university and how to use them to set you up for a fantastic start to life once you graduate. I'm your host George Haughie and in this short episode we'll be discussing how we give feedback.

We give feedback all the time. The purpose of feedback is to help yourself and the people around you improve. However, sometimes it doesn't achieve that purpose. If feedback is delivered in the wrong way, not in line with people's preferences and expectations, then it can have a negative impact on their performance and on their feelings towards you.

Because of this potential outcome, you need to consider feedback as both a transactional conversation and an emotional conversation. I'll discuss the transactional part [00:01:00] first. The transaction is that you are offering information that will hopefully help the other person improve. This could be anyone you do activities with, for example, a team member, a work colleague, or a friend, or even a combination of these.

When you know you are going to have a feedback conversation, you need to plan a few aspects of it beforehand. Firstly, if you want them to improve, then you need a clear idea of what they are not doing well, and what improvement would look like. Secondly, you need to have a list of what they are already doing well.

And thirdly, you need to make an effort to understand the contextual factors that may have affected their performance. Having a clear idea of how and what to improve is essential because vague, imprecise feedback will not help and could lead to changes you do not want to see. It also gives the [00:02:00] receiver of the feedback an idea of what to aim for and what success looks like.

Having a list of what the person has done well shows them that you have seen all their work. Not just the negative parts. And that you notice their effort. This links to the emotional aspect of feedback. It shows that you value their work, and it helps it to appear that you're being fair in your judgement.

Finally, understanding the contextual factors helps in at least three ways. The first is that it will make your feedback more relevant to their context. The second is that often people may feel that the context is responsible for how their work turned out. Not their own effort or ability. You need to understand if this is the case.

And if it is not the case, then why that is so? The third and final reason for understanding the [00:03:00] context is that it can help position you as someone who understands their situation, which may make them more inclined to follow your advice. However, a word of warning here, if you do not understand the context or their position, Don't pretend that you do.

And if they feel that you do not understand it, then don't insist that you do. Instead, accept that there may be factors you are not aware of or have not experienced. If you feel that they are resisting your advice. Do not push them or press them. It is important that they realize and accept the changes they can make themselves, and do not feel forced or pushed.

If they feel that they are being forced or pushed, then it can damage your relationship with them. That is the guidance to the transactional part of the feedback conversation. But, as you can see with some of the advice already, the emotional aspects [00:04:00] blend with the transactional part. The emotional part of feedback is important, and in some ways more important than the transactional aspect.

When you give someone feedback on their performance, you are not just commenting on their performance, but also their sense of self and their sense of their own abilities. What you may feel are just tips to help them improve could be felt as an attack on their work. If they're feeling attacked, then whatever you say will not improve their performance.

It is useful to have feedback scheduled into any piece of work you are doing, so that the people you are working with know it's going to happen regardless of whether their performance has been good or bad. Having feedback as part of the routine helps set expectations of improving performance. In contrast, unsolicited feedback is often not appreciated and can damage your relationship with them.[00:05:00]

Only give unsolicited feedback if you really feel you need to, and make it clear to them that you do feel you need to. You could even say that it would help you if you could give them some feedback, that you can't get it out of your head, and you feel it would really help their work if they just changed this one thing.

If the feedback is solicited or expected, then two other helpful practices are to ask them what they would like to receive feedback on, and how they would like to receive it. We can only improve a few things at a time, so getting a focus will help them, and it will help you because you are then giving feedback on what you have been invited to give feedback on.

Asking them how they would like to receive the feedback also gives them some control over the structure of the conversation. There are several feedback models you can suggest. The first is the [00:06:00] classic feedback sandwich, where negative feedback is given in between two bits of positive feedback. A second model is an open face sandwich, where negative feedback is given first, followed by positive feedback.

A third model, more extreme but preferred by some people, is just the negative feedback. Some people only want to hear where they can improve and may feel the positive feedback is not important or even it's insincere. A fourth model is the opposite, where they may want to hear only positive feedback.

This can happen if they've had a particularly traumatic experience or if they feel very unsure about what they are doing. This model can be seen Um, more about encouragement than about performance improvement. A fifth and final model for feedback is having a question based conversation where the other person is encouraged to find their own areas to improve and to think about how to improve [00:07:00] them.

This is the type of model encouraged in coaching practices and also works well with people who are sensitive to direct feedback. You can check out a link to these different models in the show notes to this episode. As the person giving the feedback, you need to be able to deliver feedback in these different formats and also be aware of what you prefer.

You need to have a clear idea of what feedback you want to give and how they want to receive it. You need to take into account the emotional aspect of the conversation and adjust accordingly. My final piece of advice is to practice. Giving feedback is a skill like any other. You will sometimes get it wrong and you will always be able to improve how your feedback conversations go.

But the only way to improve is to practice. And if you practice, then you will improve. Thank you for listening to this [00:08:00] short episode. If you've enjoyed this episode, please share it with a friend and consider following us so you don't miss any further episodes. The Skillscast is brought to you by the team behind the Warwick Award, the University of Warwick's Employability Skills Award and Development Scheme.

Find out more at warwick. ac. uk forward slash Warwick Award.

Season 2 Episode 15 - Focus

Want to improve your focus but not sure how? in this Skillscast Short episode Tom Greenaway shares tips on how to improve your focus, eliminate distractions, and complete your goals.

Season 2 Episode 14 - Warwick Enterprise

Do you want to start a business? Learn entrepreneurial skills? Warwick Enterprise can sort you out. Listen to this interview with Chris Wilkinson, Student Innovation Officer to learn how to get started.
Learn more about Warwick Enterprise here -⁠Unleash your potential | Warwick Enterprise

 

Season 2 Episode 13 - 'Shorts' - Getting Work Experience

Where do you start when you want to get work experience? Warwick has a toolkit to help you. Take a listen to LaiLeng from the IPWE team to learn how to get started with work experience.

Warwick TeamWork Ambassadors Chris and Anais

Season 2 Episode 12 - TeamWork International Experience Programme

Interested in getting real-world work experience at Warwick?
In this episode we are Joined by Laura Jackson, Project leader at the TeamWork International Experience Programme and two of her ambassadors, Chris and Anais, to discuss the programme, their experiences, and the skills they developed.
Learn more and sign up at⁠ TeamWork International Experience Programme

Season 2 Episode 11 - 'Shorts' - Succeeding on your first day at work

In this Skillscast short Beth Gallet discusses how to prepare, and how to make a good impression on your first day at work.
For more information about this you can check out the WorkReady work experience toolkit.

Season 2 Episode 10 - Connecting with industry experts through the 1 Hour project

The 1 Hour project connects students who are first in their families to attend university with professionals in a range of industries so they can learn about the skills needed for their potential careers and start to build a professional network.

Season 2 Episode 9 - Active Bystander Training

Warwick's Active Bystander Course has supported over 1,000 students to gain confidence in assessing and safely addressing situations relevant to student life to help build a community that embodies our ethics and values. Take a listen to some of the course participants talk about how it has positively impacted their lives and the lives of other students.

Season 2 Episode 8 - 'Shorts': Getting started with a new skill

What do you do if you want to learn something new? Where do you start and how do you get better? Check out this short and begin learning something new.

Season 2 Episode 7 - Skills development in a placement year

In this episode Tom Greenaway from the Skills Team is joined by four School of Life Sciences students, Amy, Minelli, Kaavya, and Sarah, who share their experience working on placement years, the skills they developed along the way.

Season 2 Episode 6 - Getting started with the URSS

The URSS (Undergraduate Research Support Scheme) is a great opportunity for you to do research, investigate something you care about, and develop transferable skills. Listen to part 1 of our interview with Warwick Researcher James Blake, an expert in the URSS and learn how to get started.

Season 2 Episode 5 - Developing Skills through Job Simulations with Forage

No idea about what to do after your degree? Not sure if you have the skills or experience yet to do an internship? We had a chat with Alia Alhirsi from Forage, who have a platform for this exact situation. Forage have worked with top employers to provide virtual work experience simulations. Listen to find out more.

Season 2 Episode 4 - 'Shorts': 10 tips to create and curate a positive LinkedIn presence

Want to do a LinkedIn Profile, but not sure where to start? In this short we are joined by Parmjit Dhugga who shares his top ten tips for creating and curating the best possible LinkedIn profile.

Season 2 Episode 3 - Developing creative approaches to solving problems

Let the weirdness in!

What is problem solving, and how can you do it well? In this episode skills developer Zoe Pflaeger Young interviews Rob O'Toole about creativity, problem solving, and AI.

Warwick Sport logo

Season 2 Episode 2 - Developing skills as a Sports Activator

Active Lives, Healthy Minds!

Ever wondered how becoming involved with sports can help raise your transferable skills and make you more attractive to employers? Ever thought about building on your coaching experience while at Warwick? Georgie Pilling and KoKo Taylor Takahashi share their experience organising and participating in the Sports Activators program at Warwick.

Season 2 Episode 1 - 'Shorts': Preparing for a jobs fair

Not sure what to do when you go to a career's fair? Not thought about what questions to ask or who to talk to? Listen to our short with the Careers Manager, David Molyneux, for some tips to help you get the most out of conversations with employers.

Season 1

Episode 12 - Why you should register for the Warwick Award

This time we’re covering something that has been mentioned in just about every episode; the Warwick Award. To help you understand more about the Award and why you might like to register for it yourself, we caught up with Lauren Ketteridge. Lauren is now studying for a PhD, but she also achieved the Gold level of the Warwick Award while she was an undergraduate here, and has plenty of useful insights to share.

Episode 11 - How professionalism can help you stand out

Head of the skills team here at Warwick, Ali Collins, is joined by Giorgia McDonald, who is Warwick Business School’s careers manager for undergraduates. This interview is packed full of excellent advice about professionalism – what it is, how and where you can build it, and how it might help you stand out from the crowd of 500,000 graduates who enter the job market every single year.

Episode 10 - Developing your skills through volunteering

This time our focus is something that is great not only for skills development, but many, many other things too; volunteering. In this episode, we caught up with two people with in-depth experience of Warwick Volunteers, the official Warwick society for volunteering that has an impact across the local community all year round.

Episode 09 - The importance of reflection

This time we’re focusing on a key part of learning skills, personal development and, as it happens, the Warwick Award – we’re looking at reflection, with two members of Warwick's skills team; Tom Greenaway is asking the questions of Steven Burke who has extensive interest in and experience of using reflection and reflective practice. He gives you some background to the art of reflecting, tips on how to do it, and explains how it can help improve so many parts of your life – including what you have for breakfast!

Episode 08 - How to be an entrepreneur

In this episode, we caught up with two former Warwick students who have found success setting up their own businesses – David and Sumit. Both offer great insights into why you might want to consider becoming an entrepreneur and tips on how to achieve success doing so.

Episode 07 - Why Sustainability is a vital skill to learn

This time we’re taking another closer look at one of Warwick’s 12 core skills – specifically, sustainability.

Episode 06 - How to learn a new skill

In this episode you’ll get to hear from some of my immediate colleagues in the skills team about something we’ve not yet covered here – what it takes to actually learn a skill.

Episode 05 -Skills development for women with Thrive

In this episode, we’re going to hear from four students who were part of Thrive’s pilot programme who will tell you more about the skills they’ve developed both on the programme and alongside it. More information about Thrive is available on their website.

Episode 04 - Developing your Digital Literacy

In this episode, we're joined by Jim Judges, who is an academic technologist here at Warwick and has more than 20 years of experience working in a digital realm. Across our conversation, Jim offers insights into why digital literacy is important, how it might change in the future, and why it’s important for students to think about while they are at university.

Episode 03 - Leading your own research project, with the URSS

In this episode, our focus is on the URSS and you'll hear the perspectives of four University of Warwick students who completed it in 2023.

Episode 02 - How to sell your skills when applying for jobs

In this episode, we meet Sam Merrix and Kelly Coles, both senior careers consultants at Warwick and both people who are well worth listening to if you want to give yourself the best chance of standing out to employers and kick-starting your career.

Episode 01 - How building your skills at university can help your land your first job

Our guest this episode is Fay Inverarity, who graduated from Warwick in the summer of 2022 and secured a place on the graduate scheme at Barclays Bank and who did an incredible amount of skills development while studying here.

In this chat, Fay shares some great insights about how to develop your skills while at University. Among other things, Fay shares how she’s found her first year of work, she talks about how she went about developing a range of skills while studying here, and reflects on the importance of, well, reflecting on your own skills development – particularly when thinking about applying and interviewing for jobs.

You can follow Skillscast in Spotify, Apple Podcasts, or wherever else you listen.

The artwork for the Skillscast against a gradient background. Below it are the logos for Spotify and Apple Podcasts.