Skip to main content Skip to navigation

Patrick Cronin-Coltsmann

I am a final year PhD student in the Astronomy and Astrophysics group at the University of Warwick, supervised by Dr Grant Kennedy.

My research centres on using data from the Atacama Large Millimetre/submillimetre Array (ALMA) to image and model debris discs around M-dwarf stars.

Disc detection rates are presently low around M-dwarfs: the Herschel DEBRIS survey detected just 2 debris discs from 89 M-dwarfs. However, detection rates are inherently tied to the sensitivity of the instrument used and the observation wavelength. The question remains whether or not true incidence rates for M-dwarf discs are similar to earlier type stars and it is the low luminosity of the host stars that limits the temperature and luminosity of the discs, thus requiring highly sensitive observations made at far-infrared/sub-millimetre wavelengths to detect. The alternative is that discs are indeed less common around these late type stars, perhaps due to effects that more significantly affect discs around low mass hosts such as stripping from stellar encounters or photoevaporation of the primordial disc. It is also possible that efficient planet formation around low mass stars could use up all the disc material, this ties in to exoplanet observations finding many terrestrial planets in low mass systems, a la Trappist-1. Also, M-dwarf ages span up to 10 billion years, and debris discs are typically found to be brightest when youngest, as their planetesimal belts have been depleted little by collisional evolution, so perhaps simply many M star discs have decayed past our observational sensitivities. Hence the need for the unique capabilities of ALMA. Just a handful of M-dwarf debris discs have been observed by ALMA but they will play an important role in our understanding of M-dwarf discs and the M dwarf planet formation process.

Here's a link to my first paper: ALMA imaging of the M-dwarf Fomalhaut C's debris disc! Fomalhaut C is the lowest luminosity main sequence star to host a resolved debris disc, as an M4V star, it's over ten times dimmer than the M1V AU Mic. The ensuing deficit of radiation pressure plunges the disc well into the regime of stellar wind dominance, but the star might have a tangled past with its associates, Fomalhaut A and B, that complicate the picture of the disc's formation and history. You can see some of the data below!

When processing ALMA data, we have a lot of control over how we want to tweak the necessary modelling process when Fourier transforming from the measured 'visibility' data to a sky image. One control we have is how the visibilities are weighted. We can choose to more strongly weight short or long baseline points, which in the produced image will accentuate large scale or small scale structure respectively. Depending on the scales of the structures in your image, certain baselines will be more sensitive to those structures, and we want to give these baselines more weight, but we must also consider the Signal-to-Noise Ratio (SNR) of the image. If we are using so-called 'Briggs' weighting, we can vary our 'Robust' parameter R from between -2 and 2. An R of -2 is called 'Uniform' weighting which is where all baselines are equal, this works well for high SNR data and returns a high resolution, but it does not work well for low SNR data as you can see below. An R close to 0 compromises between resolution and sensitivity. An R of +2 is called 'Natural' weighting which returns a larger point spread function (PSF) but has higher sensitivity. We can see how our PSF, also called 'the beam' and represented by the white oval, changes in the bottom left of the gif below. For this low SNR data, we prefer a Natural like weighting.

Briggs Weighting Gif

We can also introduce a 'Taper' which further down-weights long baselines, reducing sensitivity to small scales, and is equivalent to smoothing out the PSF with a Gaussian. We can see how the PSF gets larger as we increase the Taper. The disc begins to become more apparent, but quickly all detail in the image is washed out.

uv taper gif

A link to my second paper is here: ALMA's view of the M-dwarf GSC 07396-00759's edge-on debris disc: AU Mic's coeval twin in which I analyse the GSC 07396-00759 system and how our ALMA data compares with previous scattered light observations.

I also contributed to this paper on Herschel Observations of Disks around Late-type Stars, identifying the infra-red excess around TYC 7443-1102-1 as likely galaxy contamination.

I additionally have experience combing through Herschel galaxy surveys to find foreground stars with infrared excesses. In general, my astrophysics interests lie in circumstellar discs, planet formation and exoplanets. Outside of that, I do enjoy learning about ancient history, zoology and in particular paleontology, my hand-knitted dinosaurs attest to that!

I am a big fan of outreach and am always willing to take part in any sort of activities or to simply answer questions about space/my experiences! Here are a couple of art pieces of the constellation Orion and the planet Venus that I've made for outreach articles I've written:

Digital artwork of the Constellation Orion by Patrick Cronin-ColtsmannDigital artwork of the planet Venus by Patrick Cronin-Coltsmann

Full Citations:

Cronin-Coltsmann P. F., Kennedy G. M., Kalas P., Milli J., Clarke C. J., Duchêne G., Greaves J., et al., 2021, MNRAS, 504, 4497. doi:10.1093/mnras/stab1237

Cronin-Coltsmann P.F., Kennedy G. M., Adam C., Kral Q., Lestrade J.-F., Marino S., Matrà L., et al., 2022, MNRAS, 512, 4752. doi:10.1093/mnras/stac536

Tanner A., Plavchan P., Bryden G., Kennedy G., Matrà L., Cronin-Coltsmann P., Lowrance P., et al., 2020, PASP, 132, 084401. doi:10.1088/1538-3873/ab895f

id.rotated.rotated.jpg

Brookesia minima, formally the world's smallest lizard before they found a slightly smaller one.

Write to:

Patrick Cronin-Coltsmann,
Department of Physics,
University of Warwick,
Coventry CV4 7AL
UK
 

Contact details:

Office: PS.016
E-Mail: Patrick.Cronin-ColtsmannATwarwick.ac.uk