Please read our student and staff community guidance on COVID-19
Skip to main content Skip to navigation

Comment and peer review in Mahara

Feedback and peer review can be very valuable in teaching students how to constructively appraise and assess each others competencies, skills, project approach and conduct (amongst other criteria) as part of authentic, and work-based, learning. This can be achieved in Mahara through the use of comments and the peer assessment block. This guide explains how to set these up.

Comments

Comments can be enabled by the portfolio owner for pages and for individual artefacts including files, journal entries and notes. See the Mahara manual on Commenting for information on how to do this for each type of artefact.

  1. Turn on editing (pages, files, journals, notes) using the pencil edit icon.
  2. Find the Allow comments option and click to change this from No to Yes.
  3. Click Save.

For templates, enable comments on the artefacts and pages in advance, so that when the template is copied, the option is already enabled.

Comments will appear when the page is displayed (not in edit mode) at the bottom of the page but can be moved to a new location; and as a link under the artefact they were added to. Comments are not anonymous and will have the profile image and preferred name of the person who added the comment.

Peer assessment block

The peer assessment block can be added to pages by the owner of the page (e.g. when creating a template). In order for the peer assessor to access and add an assessment, as text, images, links etc., they need to be added via the Manage access section as a peer. Assessments are not anonymous and will have the profile image and preferred name of the person who added the assessment.

Add the peer assessment block to a page

  1. Turn on editing by clicking
  2. Expand the General section of the blocks menu
  3. Drag the Peer Assessment block onto one of the grey editable regions
  4. Optionally change the title (maybe consider Peer appraisal or Peer Review), and add instructions on how to add the assessment (Rules of conduct, format, sections).
  5. Click Save

Add sharing permissions for Peers

  1. Follow the instructions for sharing a page or collection to share with others.
  2. Select Search for > User and find the person to add as a peer.
  3. Use the drop-down next to the name to change the role from No special role to Peer.
  4. Click Save.

Add a peer assessment

  1. Open the page to add the assessment to. Only block headings and the peer assessment block will be visible.
  2. Click on + Add peer assessment
  3. Follow the instructions to add content.
  4. Click Save Draft to come back and finish the assessment later or click Publish to complete the process.

View a peer assessment

When the peer assessment has been published it will become visible on the page.

The information on this page relates to Mahara 19.04 and was last updated May 2020.

Contents

Filter by tool, task or content